Judges Order USDA to Pay SNAP Benefits Using Contingency Funds
Federal judges have ordered the USDA to pay November SNAP benefits, requiring use of a $6 billion contingency fund despite the government shutdown.
In a major legal decision affecting millions of Americans, two federal judges ruled Friday that the U.S. Department of Agriculture must use its $6 billion contingency fund to continue providing Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits during the ongoing government shutdown.
U.S. District Judge John McConnell in Rhode Island ruled from the bench that USDA's refusal to use the fund was causing "irreparable harm," siding with a coalition of cities and nonprofit groups that sued the agency. His decision came hours after Massachusetts Judge Indira Talwani issued a similar ruling, stating that the Trump administration was "statutorily mandated" to tap the reserve to keep food assistance flowing.
"There is no doubt that the six billion dollars in contingency funds are appropriated funds," McConnell said in court. "The shutdown of the government doesn't do away with SNAP - it just does away with the funding of it."
Rejecting USDA's argument that the funds must be preserved for future disaster needs, the judge said, "The balance of equities clearly goes on the side of ensuring that people are fed." According to court filings, SNAP serves tens of millions of Americans and costs approximately $8.6 billion per month-more than what's currently in the contingency reserve.
Judge Talwani's ruling followed a lawsuit filed by 25 states and the District of Columbia, challenging USDA's refusal to fund the program in the absence of a formal budget. She determined that USDA's interpretation of the law was flawed and that the agency has both the obligation and discretion to use already appropriated reserves when necessary.
"At core, Defendants' conclusion that USDA is statutorily prohibited from funding SNAP... is erroneous," she wrote. She added that the agency must consider whether it will authorize at least reduced benefits for November, ordering USDA officials to report back by Monday.
The USDA had argued that SNAP could not legally be funded during the shutdown because new congressional appropriations hadn't been enacted for the current fiscal year. However, both judges ruled that previously appropriated funds could-and must-be used to avoid a lapse in critical food aid.
The rulings reflect rising pressure on the federal government to safeguard food security during the shutdown, especially for low-income families, children, seniors, and the disabled who rely heavily on SNAP. Advocacy groups and state governments had warned that failure to issue benefits could lead to severe hunger impacts and strain on local food banks.
While the legal decisions provide immediate relief, the $6 billion reserve will not cover a full month of SNAP payments, leaving future funding uncertain unless Congress passes a new appropriations bill or extends emergency authority.
For now, however, the court has spoken: the USDA must act to ensure Americans receive their food benefits, even as Washington remains locked in a budgetary standoff.
